Reading for and Entering the Conversation

Task 1: Read Laurie Waye, ‘The Literature Review as a Party’, Managing your Thesis or Dissertation: A Workbook for Graduate Students (Dubuque, IA: Kendall Hunt, 2011), 8-9. (You might like to also take a look at the extract from Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein on ‘Reading for the Conversation’, They Say/I Say: The Moves that Matter in Academic Writing, 2nd ed. (New York: WW Norton, 2010).)

Task 2: Let’s say we are conducting a research project on the role of arts funding in Australia. I’ve included here some different perspectives on this topic. Pretend that this is the scope of the existing research. Using the templates from Graff and Birkenstein, summarise the existing ‘conversation’ as a brief literature review, and find a way to enter the conversation yourself. What can you add? Where is the gap?


*** Extract 1 *** 

[T]here is still massive discrepancy between the amounts of funding that go into the major performing arts companies and how much goes into everything else combined.

My favourite little factoid is that Opera Australia last year received more funding from the Australia Council than all the applicants for all 6 of the Australia Council's major artform boards combined. Opera Australia's $18.3 million was more than the entire competitive funds for literature ($4.2m), music ($3.6m), theatre ($2.5m), dance ($1.8m) visual arts ($4.8m) and inter-arts or cross artform projects ($0.8m) that combined totalled just $17.6 million. That's one opera company receiving more than seven hundred and eighty one separate projects, organisations and individuals competitively funded across all those forms.

Or to put it another way the annual Opera Australia budget could support the measly $348,377 that the Australia Council's Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Arts Board gave out last year for more than 50 years. Putting aside all the social justice arguments, the equity issues, and allowing yourself to ignore Australia's unique responsibility as custodians of an ancient and unique living culture: on purely cynical economic and cultural cachet terms aren't Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander artists just a much, much, much better investment?

-- Marcus Westbury. ‘Arts Funding Reality Check.’ The Drum 21 Sept. 2010.

 

*** Extract 2 *** 

Public science and research funding in Australia, as in most of the world, is based on a process that has remained largely unchanged for 60 years. This begins with calls for submissions of reasonably detailed project proposals. These then pass through expert panels (e.g. the Australian Research Council) and then on to the peer review process in which carefully selected "peers" evaluate the proposals and write detailed reports, before passing these back to the panels for final judgement. The high-level of process and accountability makes this the gold standard for taxpayer-sourced public funding of research (philanthropic trust funding often mirrors this architecture).

But it is expensive to run, and onerous to all involved. Perhaps one in ten projects proposed will be funded. The amounts of time and effort invested by all those seeking funding will tend toward the expected value of the grants, meaning that once overhead costs to panels and reviewers are added in, these function to a considerable degree as a redistribution mechanism. Rob Brooks wrote about this on The Conversation last year.

The new model the computer scientists propose bypasses this expert-panel-and-peer-review system altogether by simply taking the whole public lump of funding, and allocating it unconditionally (yes, unconditionally) to all "eligible" scientific researchers. It would thus function like a kind of "basic income".

They calculate that if the National Science Foundation budget in the US were divided among all who applied for funding, it would deliver about US$100,000 per scientist. The problem with this, apart from an expected blowout in the number of people who claim to be scientists, is that we've just lost oversight, accountability and peer review.

So here's what the computer scientists propose: everyone who receives funding gives some fraction (say 50% of their previous year's funding) to other scientists whose work they like or think particularly interesting and valuable. That fraction can be distributed among one or many. The idea is that this works as a collective-allocation mechanism that basically crowd-sources peer review, and with the added advantage that it funds people, not projects. It also gets the incentives right for scientists to concentrate on clear communication of their findings and the value of research.

-- Jason Potts. ‘A Peer Funding Model for the Arts?’ The Conversation 14 Jan. 2014.

 

*** Extract 3 *** 

Like everything else, the question of whether to give funding to humanities research projects is a matter of balance. Some humanities projects do seem, at face value at least, quite wasteful and unnecessary, especially in times of resource shortage, and when there are so many deserving projects in medicine and related fields.

For example, does the country really need to spend A$325,183 on a topic about “the experiences of LGBTI (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex) people in natural disasters”? LGBTI people are, after all, just people. Or $578,792 on the history of an ignored credit instrument in Florentine economic and social and religious life from 1570-1790? I have no disrespect for the researchers, or their projects, but there is a case for claiming that some projects should perhaps not be funded at all.

As a quite separate point, if it is decided that funding arts is important - and I think it is - the amounts allocated to (some) arts research funding can also sometimes seem manifestly excessive (where a much smaller amount might do). I recall the great Australian philosopher, Emeritus Professor J. J. C. Smart, telling me that he had no interest in applying for grants: all he needed to do philosophy was paper and a pencil. Having no need for funding, or a computer, didn’t stop his impressive contributions to the discipline.

Personally, I’m not that interested in credit instruments in Florentine society, let alone ones that have been ignored. So I can see why some people question why an investigation of this nature requires such an investment. I stress that I have not read the application in question, which, for all I know, might well make a persuasive case. Prima facie however, a project of this kind appears to be a case of simply needing paper, pencils and a good library. What justification could there be for such vast expense?

-- Martin Davies. ‘A Farewell to Arts: On Philosophy, ARC Funding and “Waste.”’ The Conversation 17 Oct. 2013.

 

*** Extract 4 *** 

 Why should the arts receive any subsidy at all? The first argument is that almost everyone else is subsidised too, so why not the arts? In this country agriculture, manufacturing, construction and many other industries, including communications and computing – not to mention banking – receive far more (both proportionately and absolutely) in direct subsidy than do the arts, even though many of these sectors contributes less in real terms to the economy. For the arts are hugely beneficial to UK plc. This is the second argument.

The arts in this country are a major financial success story. The income from creative industries generates revenues of around £112.5bn, and they employ more than 1.3 million people, which is 5% of the total employed workforce in the UK. Arts exports contribute around £10.3bn to the balance of trade, and the industries account for over 5% of GDP. The value of the creative industries to UK gross domestic product is, therefore, greater than the contribution of any of our manufacturing industries. […]

The removal of subsidy would mean that most galleries and museums in this country would close, as would almost all concert halls and producing theatres. Even a small series of further cutbacks would cut a swathe through these places and surrounding communities and businesses. The landscape would be truly barren. Art consists not only of the so-called elite forms of metropolitan opera or minority-interest visual art, it is also every provincial museum schoolchildren visit and the galleries visited by many millions of people across the UK every week. It is the local pantomime and the National Theatre. It is very often the band playing in a small venue and the orchestras at the Proms. It is the novels we read and the films we download. More people interact with art in this country than with any other single activity – 90% of us, according to another independent study. […]

Yet the most profound argument for art runs much deeper than any of this. Art, very simply, is how we comment on our world, how we speak truth to power. It promotes equality and solidarity; it is a vital form of experiment and risk. It comforts, offers consolation and escape. It challenges, confronts and exposes. It tells us who we are as a society at given moments in history, and articulates our relationships with the world around us. Not all art is popular, not all art is powerful, but some is both, and we will lose it all if we don't fund it.

-- Jonathan Holmes. ‘Why We Must Fund the Arts.’ The Guardian 28 Feb. 2010.

 

*** Extract 5 *** 

Arts supporters in the United States often look to our more cultured brothers and sisters across the Atlantic Ocean with longing for their civilized systems of arts funding that provide far more capital per resident than our own. The numbers just look so inviting: Germany's federal government, for example, plowed some 1.22 billion euros, or about $1.7 billion, into its cultural ecosystem in 2007. That investment of over $20 per German citizen absolutely dwarfs the 41 cents per red-blooded American provided by the NEA. What artist wouldn't want to live there?

But that comparison is deceiving, because United States has a secret weapon: the charitable tax deduction, and more importantly, the culture of private giving that has grown up around it. It turns out that the counterpart to all that money that Americans give annually to the arts just doesn't exist in Germany, or any other developed country for that matter. Oh, to be sure, it would be inaccurate to say that there is no private giving in Germany - there is, and there are tax incentives for it too. But according to a 2006 analysis by Charities Aid Foundation, the USA's charitable giving is more than seven times that of Germany's as a percentage of GDP - and no other country in the sample comes even as close as half. Assuming that the percentage of money given to the arts is comparable between countries, we can figure that German arts organizations receive something on the order of $250 million per year in private funding, compared to $13.3 billion on our side of the pond. How do you like them apples, Berlin?

Perhaps that's why, in the face of recession-induced cuts, a number of governments in Europe are starting to give the American model more serious consideration -- and a number of European arts organizations are going after American donors. Which highlights another downside of a government-dominant system: any shock to public revenue streams could be life or death to grant recipients, rather than just another challenge to overcome. Asurvey of arts groups in the UK found that more than a ninth of those who lost their funding in a round of government cuts intend to close up shop, and another 22% considered themselves at risk of failure. And this was after relatively mild cuts of 15% from Arts Council England, which is already a bit of a hybrid between the European and American system. Dutch cuts of 25% last year resulted in a dramatic reshaping of the national cultural landscape that particularly affected smaller and grassroots institutions. Following federal government cuts of 100% in 2010, staff at Sarajevo's National Museum have gone unpaid for seven months! Here in the US, we fight hard every year for the NEA to survive, and we should - but there is nevertheless some comfort in knowing that if it goes away, the arts won't be dragged down the drain with it.

-- Ian David Moss. ‘Federal Government Money is not the Best Way to Fund the Arts.’ Huffington Post 5 Jan. 2012.

You have completed 100% of the lesson
100%