Presenting the Literature Review
A literature review, as opposed to an annotated bibliography, does take the form of continuous prose – it’s an essay. However, it only discusses the extant literature in your fields, rather than an introducing any new analysis. You should, by all means, critique and evaluate that literature, but at this stage you don’t introduce your new contributions. As the USQ guide to writing a literature review puts it, while ‘in other kinds of expository writing, you use relevant literature to support the discussion of your thesis; in a literature review, the literature itself is the subject of discussion.’
There’s no precise guide for length, and it will depend on how much research there has already been in your area. The USQ guide suggests around 20+ titles for Honours and 40+ for Masters, but remember that it will probably constitute the bulk of your introduction, and your introduction will probably be around 20-25% of your thesis, so use that as a general guide. Just be sure to cover the seminal sources in your field. Ridley’s book provides a number of different examples of the lengths and organisational principles of a literature review, which you might find it helpful to examine.
But what happens if there’s very little research in your field? This would be unsurprising, actually, because part of the remit of a dissertation, at any level, is originality. If your work is really novel, though, there might not be a lot of material directly related to your project on which you can draw. Instead, think about those fields which intersect to form your own project. Others will have addressed similar problems in a different context, or the same context with different problems. They might have used your approach, but not in your field. Consider the field beyond your immediate project and draw on this to justify the gap you’ve identified for your original research.
You might have previously completed an annotated bibliography. In fact, your Endnote library is a great way to put this together, and it can be a good starting point for your literature review. However, annotated bibliographies are structured rather simply: they describe and evaluate one critic after another, establishing a tradition, at the end of which comes their own project. However, this can represent a rather narrow view, and is not really suitable for a sophisticated research project like the ones you are conducting.
A better way to structure your literature review is by grouping together particular researchers, projects, schools of thought, periods of time, or even methodological approaches. This way you can compare them both within an across those groupings, but more importantly, by gathering together the research in this way your literature review is a valuable contribution in its own right. In fact, some journal articles are entirely literature reviews – a kind of running evaluation of the work in the field. Publishing one of these can be a very quick way to get yourself lots of citations (that is – impact)!
Some possible organising principles are (and these are taken from the very handy guide available at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill):
- Chronological
- This could be by publication date or by historical trends.
- Thematic
- Organised around topics or issues addressed in the literature. Chronology might still play a part in this.
- Methodological
- Sorted by different methodological or theoretical approaches to the issue.
Consider the story you are telling about the context for your research.