Literature Review = A Party

In Laurie Waye’s very useful analogy (in the reading attached to this module), the literature review is like a party:

You enter a party, late. You don’t know anyone, but they are engaged in a heated debate. You can’t enter the discussion until you have listened long enough to know who has said what, and who is agreeing with whom. The issues become clearer the more you listen, and you learn the names of the people that most of the party-goers are listening to. Eventually you build up enough contextual and background knowledge to add your own ideas to the conversation, but not before you understand how to appropriately add your ideas. (8)

This is the best explanation of a literature review, and even of the function of research, that I have ever come across, and I use it regularly. Graff and Birkenstein, in They Say/I Say, make a similar analogy, and call research and the literature review ‘entering the conversation’. This book is a fantastic resource which I highly recommend (a section of this book is also attached to this module).

By the time you complete your thesis, you will be a world expert on your topic! In order to become this, however, you need to first be familiar with the existing expertise – or as Graff and Birkenstein put it, the existing conversation. As Diana Ridley notes,

it is important to explore the field in which you are going to do your research and gain a thorough awareness and understanding of current work and perspectives in the area so that you can position your own research clearly on the academic map of knowledge creation. An essential aspect of academic research is that it has connections with the work of others. (1)

What we might note, then, is that the literature review is both a product and a process (Ridley 3). It is the part of your thesis which shows off your understanding of the field, but it is also the practice of reading and reviewing that literature as part of the research process. It is, says Ridley, ‘the driving force and jumping-off point for your own research investigation’ (3).

You have completed 100% of the lesson
100%