What’s in an abstract?
The structure of any kind of report in the Arts and Humanities – whether it is a book, an article, a chapter, or a thesis – is much looser than its counterpart in the sciences. A scientific paper looks like this:
- Background
- Objective/Aims
- Method
- Results
- Conclusion
Even though we don’t have ready-made sections with these headings, our theses still cover all of this information – our results, for example, are really the bulk of the written piece, and will run on for many, many pages, whereas a scientific article might take only a few paragraphs to report this. The ‘Background’ might be seen to correspond to our ‘Literature Review’, which is the topic of our discussion in a later module. This section of your thesis will lay out the field in your relevant areas, and explain how your project fits into that field. It identifies the gap that your project will fill. Objectives and aims correspond to the research questions we’ll ask, and what we will argue, while the method is entwined with those questions and how we will extract that information. That, too, is the focus of one of our upcoming classes.
Even though we don’t adopt this precise structure, the scientific model for writing can be very helpful when it comes to sorting out what we should include in our thesis. Where it’s perhaps most useful is when we come to write our abstract. An abstract is a condensed version of the entire thesis. When it comes to published work, and as you will know from your own research experience, much of the time the title and abstract are all that someone will read. If you don’t tell them what is important about your research right there, they will either not read it, or be frustrated by the end of your piece because you claimed you did or found something which you did not. Your goal in writing a good abstract, and a good title, then, is making each of them a perfect mirror of the thesis itself, in a progressively reduced form. There is a widespread competition for postgraduates called the ‘Three-Minute Thesis’ competition. It challenges postgrads to explain their thesis in three minutes or less. When you write your abstract, you are doing that in approximately 250 words (that’s the most typical length for an abstract, and the length designated for your assignment in this course). The title will do it in around 15 words. As you can probably tell, then, you need to have a clear idea of what you’re doing so that you can articulate it so succinctly to someone else.
That scientific model of background, aims, method, results and conclusion might be rephrased, for our purposes, to ask a number of key questions about your project. By answering these questions, you’ll be able to put together a strong abstract. You don’t need to present them in this order, but the elements are necessary. These are:
- What
will your project do?
- This requires a brief recognition of the existing field (the background of the study) and your aims for the current research. How will you fill the gap by asking new questions or interrogating old ones?
- Remember that you don’t have to phrase your questions as questions – instead of writing your research question, ‘How is war represented in media and art in the decade following 9/11?’ for example, you could write, ‘This thesis investigates how war is represented in media and art in the decade following 9/11’.
- How will you do it?
- This is your method. Surveys? Interviews? Textual analysis? Observations?
- Why
are you doing it this way?
- Methodology. What will that method enable you to do or show?
- What
do you think you will find out or conclude?
- Argument or conclusion – the answer to your research question. (For your ‘working abstract’ assignment, this will be a guess, but phrase it as if it is the given conclusion.)
- Why
does it matter? What impact will your work have? What will it contribute?
- What is the significance of your research? Why are you spending your time and perhaps someone else’s money to do this? Social/educational/philosophical/cultural value?
Two notes:
- Tense: science papers tend to write in past tense. They describe what was done in a project and what it found out. In the arts and humanities, we usually write in present or even future tense: The thesis will show …, The thesis concludes that …. You should consult other abstracts in your field (use the digitised library) to see how others have done this before you.
- References: abstracts usually do not contain references. You should only include quotations or references if they are absolutely vital, so for example if your thesis is a direct response to an important claim made by someone else.
Ensure that your abstract is clear and specific. If you provide too little information, or vague information, you will make it harder for your reader to evaluate the relevance of your work. Arthur E. Baue points this out in an article perfectly titled, ‘Writing a Good Abstract is not Abstract Writing’. He notes that ‘For example, an author describing a new operative procedure stated that he “had a limited experience which would be described.” Did this mean that he had a series of 20 such operations, five years’ experience, or a single patient he had operated on last week?’ (11). In an abstract, every word must work hard to earn its place. Now let's work through some examples and think about the work of each sentence and what they add to the abstract. This is the time to get out your red pen!